Pitfalls to Objective Economic Thinking

19 Apr
Most people bring a bundle of biases and preconceptions when thinking about eco­nomic issues. For example, you might think that corporate profits are excessive or that lending money is always superior to borrowing money. Perhaps you believe that government is necessarily less efficient than businesses or that more govern­ment regulation is always better than less.
Fallacy of Composition
Another pitfall in economic thinking is the assumption that what is true for one individual or part of a whole is necessarily true for a group of individuals or the whole. This is a logical fallacy called the fallacy of composition; the assumption is not correct. A statement that is valid for an individual or part is not necessarily valid for the larger group or whole.
Example1:You are at a football game and the home team makes an outstanding play. In the excitement, you leap to your feet to get a better view. A valid statement: “If you, an individual, stand, your view of the game is improved.” But is this also true for the group—for everyone watching the play? Not necessarily. If everyone stands to watch the play, nobody— including you—will probably have a better view than when all remain seated.
Example2(economic):An individual farmer who reaps a par­ticularly large crop is likely to realize a sharp gain in income. But this statement can­not be generalized to farmers as a group . The individual farmer’s large or “bumper” crop will not noticeably influence (reduce) crop prices because each farmer pro­duces a negligible fraction of the total farm output. But for all farmers as a group, prices decline when total output increases. Thus, if all farmers reap bumper crops, the total output of farm products will rise, depressing crop prices. If the price declines are relatively large, total farm income might actually fall.
Causation Fallacies 
   Two important causation fallacies often interfere with economic thinking.
You must think very carefully before concluding that because event A precedes event B, A is the cause of B. This kind of faulty reasoning is known as the post hoc, ergo propter hoc or “after this, therefore because of this” fallacy.
Example: Suppose that early each spring the medicine man of a tribe performs a special dance. A week or so later the trees and grass turn green. Can we safely con­clude that event A, the medicine man’s dance, has caused event B, the landscape’s turning green? Obviously not. The rooster crows before dawn, but that does not mean the rooster is responsible for the sunrise!
A professional football team hires a new coach and the team’s record improves. Is the new coach the cause? Maybe. But perhaps the presence of more experienced and talented players or an easier schedule is the true cause.     
Do not confuse correlation, or connection, with causation. Correlation between two events or two sets of data indicates only that they are associated in some systematic and dependable way. For example, we may find that when variable X increases, Y also increases. But this correlation does not necessarily mean that there is causa­tion—that an increase in X is the cause of an increase in Y. The relationship could be purely coincidental or dependent on some other factor, Z, not included in the analysis.
Here is an example: Economists have found a positive correlation between edu­cation and income. In general, people with more education earn higher incomes than those with less education. Common sense suggests education is the cause and higher incomes are the effect; more education implies a more knowledgeable and productive worker, and such workers receive larger salaries.

One Response to “Pitfalls to Objective Economic Thinking”

  1. james banda November 10, 2013 at 3:23 PM #

    i like your explanation keep on giving me more details about economics in my account.thanks

Leave a Reply (don't forget to subscribe) :

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: